Garbage Disposal Vs Trash Can? What’s Better For The Environment?

Myth: Putting Food Waste Down the Disposal Is Greener Than in the Trash

Trash Talk: Are Sink Garbage Disposals Good for the Environment? Are Garbage Disposals Bad?

OMG hold your nose! There’s a mystery substance at the back of the fridge, and it’s scaring all the other food with its excessive stink. Now what? Pitching the moldy glob straight into the garbage disposal in the sink means it can basically disappear from your life instantly, i.e., not exponentially increase the gross factor in your trashcan days before garbage pickup. But that’s not the only thing in-sink garbage disposals have going for ’em. On top of the sheer convenience of it all, the rumors are true—garbage disposals are generally a greener option than trashcans.

Let’s get into the nitty gritty of this garbage disposal vs trash can comparison…

Garbage disposals, which have been heralded as the “next great tool for urban sustainability,” not only reduce the amount of diesel fuel and emissions associated with driving garbage trucks around town—but also carry this uneaten waste along to the wastewater treatment plant, where it can actually be used to produce resources like fertilizer and clean energy.

But let’s not get ahead of ourselves here. Though garbage disposals do have some clear benefits over trashcans, they are not the greenest way to dispose of your uneaten food, according to life cycle analysis expert Eric Masanet, PhD, of Northwestern University, and Debra Shore, commissioner of the Metropolitan Water Reclamation District of Greater Chicago.

What’s Greener than a Garbage Disposal?

Based on a variety of research and their own professional experience, both Masanet and Shore agree that the hierarchy of green ways to dispose of food goes like this, from least green to most:

  • Not-so-green: Throwing it in a trashcan headed for the landfill
  • Light green: Running it through the garbage disposal, from which it then heads to the wastewater treatment plant
  • Green: Toss it in your compost bin for efficient composting
  • Greenest ever: Reduce the amount of food we waste in the first place! Globally we waste about a third of our food every year. Talk about an environmental footprint.

Need more convincing on the garbage disposal vs. trash front? Here’s a brief DL on food waste disposals.

Getting Down and Dirty With Disposal Science

In determining whether one thing is greener than another, Masanet reminds us that it’s not just energy and water usage or greenhouse gas emissions we must consider, but all of them together and more. So, as we embark on this mini garbage disposal life cycle analysis, we’ll do our best to keep it fun (but, in all honesty, it may not be as entertaining as these laugh-out-loud ridic cat GIFs—you’re welcome). Let’s dig a little deeper in this garbage disposal vs trash investigation.

So, what exactly is green about garbage disposals? Plenty. At the most basic level, they simply help lighten the load for emissions-spewing garbage trucks. The most intriguing of their eco-perks, however, is that disposals have some major hidden value.

Most wastewater facilities skim out food scraps and return these nutrient-rich biosolids to soil as fertilizer for agriculture production and public parks—like the much buzzed-about Maggie Daley Park in Chicago.

(Hidden) Benefits of Garbage Disposals

Moreover, as Shore explains, when we send food scraps down the sink via our garbage disposals and to wastewater treatment plants like the ones in Cook County, Ill., it is broken down by bacteria in a process called anaerobic digestion, which allows us to capture the methane generated by decomposition of organic matter. Sorta like in this simple (we wish!) flow chart from the EPA

So—rather than those greenhouse gases (GHGs) being released into the already overtaxed atmosphere, they are instead converted to electricity or biofuel, aka, clean energy. This is a big deal, considering that a Journal of Cleaner Production article found that the global waste sector is responsible for 3 percent of greenhouse gases.

Meanwhile, in landfills, the same decomposition is occurring, but on a larger scale and generally without as efficient a system for energy recovery. “Sending food waste to a landfill isn’t all bad if the landfill has methane recovery, which is a growing trend,” explains Masanet. For example, he mentions that Apple uses landfill gas to power some of its data centers. But landfill gas recovery is simply not as efficient as recovering gas from food scraps in wastewater, because wastewater treatment systems are working with much more concentrated food waste than landfills.

Sound like a pipe dream to turn ground-up food waste into clean energy? Shore assures us it’s not, directing our attention to the East Bay Municipal Utility District in Oakland, Calif., which seven years ago became the first wastewater treatment plant in the nation to convert post-consumer food scraps to energy via anaerobic digestion. And, she adds, Chicago’s Metropolitan Water Reclamation District now captures and uses between 50-80 percent of the methane generated at its treatment plants, a very attractive alternative to releasing those greenhouse gases.

Even if you don’t live in Chicago or Oakland, anaerobic digester systems are becoming more common in bigger cities. The EPA is all over this potential, and estimates that if just half of the food waste generated each year in the U.S. were to go through a anaerobic digester process to collect the methane from it, we would generate enough electricity to power over 2.5 million homes for a year.

Ah, But Garbage Disposals Aren’t Without Downsides

But wait! Garbage disposals are not without their impact, too, from the water and electricity needed to grind food scraps down the pipes, to the material needed to build these contraptions. Garbage disposals may also slightly contribute to nutrient overload in waterways—which, as everyone around Lake Erie recently learned the hard way, can pollute the heck out of our drinking water supply. This study in the Journal of Cleaner Production found that sink garbage disposals were responsible for about 2.1 percent of nutrient overload in the water—a much higher percentage than landfill trash and composting—but relatively quite minor compared with nonpoint source pollution, aka runoff from farms and fertilizer-spiked stormwater.

But…we still haven’t tackled the heart of the problem. “If you’ve got food waste, composting is typically best,” comments Masanet. “But even better is to not generate the food waste in the first place!

Aren’t Garbage Disposals Bad for Your Pipes?

We’ve heard from plenty of plumbers that garbage disposals are bad for your pipes. Your garbage disposal allows you to put food down the drain, which could potentially clog your pipes. Of course this is a risk. But, keep in mind that plumbers only see the “problem pipes”, which are often clogged with food scraps, so they’re a bit leery of garbage disposals in general.

However, if you’re careful not to put any of the forbidden foods down the garbage disposal, you really should not have a problem. Avoid the obvious “no-no’s” like grease, coffee grounds, egg shells, and fibrous vegetables like corn husks, potato peels, onion skins, and celery, and you should be fine.

Be sure to use plenty of cold water as you grind, and for 15 seconds or so after grinding, to wash all those food particles down the drain. From time to time, you can run a few ice cubes through the garbage disposal, to keep the blades sharp and efficient, so they can do a thorough job.

Finally, make sure your garbage disposal is a good, quality model, with sufficient horsepower to not jam easily, and to grind up those food scraps well, leaving only finely ground food particles.

Leaving No Leftover Behind – An Even Better Solution than the Garbage Disposal or Trash

The real problem is not how we deal with trashed food, but that we waste so much in the first place. Globally, we waste about a third of our food supply, according to a report for the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. In the U.S. that number is closer to 40 percent of food, which represents more than a 50 percent increase in domestic food waste since 1974.

Yes, people are going hungry and we’re wasting money, energy, and water on food we don’t eat. According to this 2009 study, we’re using a quarter of our nation’s freshwater consumption and roughly 300 million barrels of oil per year to grow food no one ever eats.

How did we get to this point? Masanet thinks a lot of it has to do with our day-to-day shopping habits—we buy too much, don’t plan properly, get confused by sell-by dates, and often let what we’ve bought go bad. The good news is that there are some easy fixes for it.

EcoMyth Outcome: Garbage Disposal Vs Trash: Winner Confirmed, But…

Tossing food waste down the garbage disposal is generally greener than trashing it for a variety of reasons, one primary reason being that it more efficiently converts food waste into energy.

But, the sink disposal process still requires resources like water and energy to function, and can sometimes contribute to nutrient overload in our waterways. That’s why the greenest way to dispose of food waste is to compost—and the greenest thing to do overall is to reduce food waste in the first place.

Do One Green Thing

Reduce food waste by making a grocery list. (Yes, there’s an app for that!) or just use Google Keep (where you can readily share shopping lists amongst family members. (This works so much better than random bits of paper – your family can actually update it in real-time while you’re at the grocery store!)

Also…Reduce your own food waste:

  • Plan your weekly meals before shopping, and don’t buy more than you need for each menu item
  • Learn the difference between best-by, use-by, and sell-by dates so you don’t inadvertently pitch food still worth eating
  • Do not fear less-than-beautiful produce. As we’ve learned from the farmer’s market movement, sometimes organic is just less attractive. But it still tastes good!
  • Eat your leftovers—and challenge yourself to use them creatively (which doesn’t mean to overeat – just have a “leftovers” meal.

And…compost if you can:

  • If you’ve got yard space, follow Shore’s example and start composting already! Not sure how to do it? Check out these Composting 101 tips
  • If you don’t have outdoor space, try an under-the-sink option like this. Shore points out that even if you can’t use it all yourself, you can always share it with a community garden
  • More and more, waste disposal companies are offering a compost pickup service as well. It’s as simple as recycling!